Skip sub-navigation
Post Occupancy Evaluation
Post occupancy evaluation (POE) provides a structured review of the process of delivering a capital project as well as a review of operational, functional and strategic performance of the building following occupation. This is a recognised way of providing feedback on the performance of the project throughout a building's lifecycle from initial concept through to occupation.
Generally carried out over three reporting periods to gain robust data on the building performance, the SFC Post Occupancy Evaluation Guidance promotes that the process follows three consecutive stages:
- Operational Review undertaken 3-6 months following handover: comprises a detailed post-project evaluation of the procurement and delivery process, as well as an indicative assessment of the building in-use to identify any initial occupational and operational issues.
- Functional Performance Review undertaken 12-18 months following handover: allows occupants the opportunity to settle into the building, identify any chronic problems and enables a full seasonal cycle to have been completed so that performance under different seasonal conditions can be captured. The Functional Performance Review is more detailed than the Operational Review and focuses on the assessment of functional and technical performance through occupant consultation as well as operational issues via energy, water usage and running cost audits.
- Strategic Review undertaken 3-5 years following handover: takes a longer term view of how far the building has met the original needs stated within the project business case, performance in the longer term and whether changes need to be implemented. It also provides the opportunity to re-evaluate the whole procurement process and to re-examine the functional and technical performance requirements to inform future estate strategies.
In a bid to capture lessons learned and demonstrate the significant benefits gained from recent substantial investments in the college and university sectors estate, SFC appointed BRE (Building Research Establishment) to undertake the POE of thirteen recently completed capital projects; twelve college projects and one university project.
Whilst it has not been possible to evaluate every project at each stage in the POE process due to the timing of project handover/occupation and the appointment of BRE , the findings captured to date are provided in the reports that follow. This table will be updated as new POE reports are finalised.
Post Occupancy Evaluation reports
| Institution |
POE review reports |
|
|
Operational |
Functional performance |
Strategic performance |
|
Anniesland College |
to follow |
to follow |
to follow |
|
Borders College - Hawick campus |
to follow |
to follow |
to follow |
|
Borders College - Borders campus |
final report |
to follow |
to follow |
|
Cardonald College |
- |
to follow |
to follow |
|
Carnegie College |
- |
final report |
to follow |
|
Cumbernauld College |
- |
final report |
to follow |
|
Dumfries & Galloway College |
to follow |
to follow |
to follow |
|
Jewel & Esk College - Edinburgh campus (now Edinburgh College) |
to follow |
to follow |
to follow |
|
Jewel & Esk College - Midlothian campus (now Edinburgh College) |
to follow |
to follow |
to follow |
|
John Wheatley College |
- |
final report |
to follow |
|
Langside College |
to follow |
to follow |
to follow |
|
Motherwell College |
final report |
to follow |
to follow |
|
North Glasgow College |
final report |
to follow |
to follow |
|
Queen Margaret University (QMU) |
final report |
to follow |
to follow |
|
South Lanarkshire College |
- |
to follow |
to follow |